An important basic concept in the treatment of heartworm infection is that there are adult heartworms in the heart and pulmonary arteries to be killed and there are microfilariae circulating in the bloodstream to be killed and one medication cannot be used to do both jobs. Heartgard30 and Interceptor, the main heartworm preventives available commercially, will kill microfilariae. Dogs on heartworm preventive, even if infected with adult heartworms, will not test positive for microfilariae. L3's are readily killed by Interceptor but not by Heartgard30. Interceptor and Heartgard30 both act primarily on the L4's living in the skin. After a dose of either medication, any L4's present will be wiped out. Heartgard30 is also able to kill the younger L5's.
DIETHYLCARBAMAZINE (FILARIBITS made by Pfizer). Diethylcarbamazine, known as DEC and sold under the trade name Filaribits, must be given daily to prevent heartworm infection. It acts by killing L3s and L4s before they develop further and begin their migration into the vasculature. This approach is started right at the start of the mosquito season and must be continued for sixty days after any frost, or it may be continued all year. However, you must be aware that forgetting to give your pet his daily treatment for a day or two during the height of the mosquito season could possibly put your pet at risk. If you chose to use this treatement method, your pet should have a filter test done before starting on heartworm preventative, as an infected pet can develop an anaphylactic reaction. This means a negative heartworm test is a must before beginning the use of this medication. DEC does nothing against other common parasites but is available with Oxybendazole added (Filaribits Plus) to control hookworms, whipworms, and roundworms.
IVERMECTIN (HEARTGARD30 made by Merck) represented a huge breakthrough in heartworm prevention. Preventive medication for the first time could be given once a month instead of daily. This medication utilizes an extremely low dose of ivermectin which is adequate to kill any L4s which are inhabiting the pets skin tissues at the time the medication is given. In other words, infection takes place but is halted every month when the medication is administered.
If ivermectin is inadvertently given to a heartworm infected dog with circulating microfilariae adverse reactions would not be expected; in fact, this product is commonly used in the treatment of active infection to clear microfilariae safely. This means, however, that giving this product to a dog with heartworm will kill all circulating microfilariae and the dog will test erroneously heartworm negative by Difil or Knotts testing. In addition to killing microfilariae, ivermectin will also suppress reproduction in the adult female worms.
There is also a phenomenon called the Reach back effect. This means that if a dog goes off heartworm preventive medication for a prolonged period (four months was the time tested), re-starting ivermectin could still prevent adult heartworms from developing in the heart. Ivermectin at the heartworm preventive dose is not strong enough to kill common intestinal parasites but it is available with pyrantel pamoate included (Heartgard30 PLUS) to control hookworms and roundworms.
There are breed related sensitivities with ivermectin (i.e. collie-related breeds have some difficulties) though at the very low doses used in the prevention of Heartworm disease are not a problem for any breed. (Note that Merck has selected Lassie as the posterdog for their products).There have been numerous discussions about the safety, or lack of safety, of using ivermectin-based heartworm prevention in collies and other herding breeds of dogs. You should ask the breeder of your collie if a sensitivity to Ivermectin has been noticed.
Much of the concern over the safety of ivermectin began when this medication was first tested in dogs for toxicity studies. In the initial testing of ivermectin, the drug was tested in Beagles to see at what dose clinical signs of toxicity would develop. Later, these same studies were performed on Collies and it was found that Collies had clinical signs of toxicosis at much lower doses of ivermectin than the Beagles did. Therefore, at the time, a warning was issued that collies and collie mixes should not be given the newly approved heartworm preventative containing ivermectin as the active ingredient.
After these initial toxicity studies were done, further studies were done to determine if the dose of ivermectin present in the monthly medication would cause a problem in collies. As a reference, the dose of ivermectin in Heartgard is 6 - 12 micrograms per kg of body weight. In studies that have been done, doses of more than 50 micrograms per kg have been tested in collies to determine toxicity at many times the dose in Heartgard.
The signs of toxicosis seen in clinical trials varied in their severity. Early signs of toxicosis included salivation, dilated pupils, vomiting, tremors, and difficulty walking (ataxia). Severe signs of toxicosis included weakness, inability to stand (recumbency), nonresponsiveness, stupor, and coma.
In several of these type of studies, there were collies that seemed to react to ivermectin, and other collies that did not react to the ivermectin. It has been suggested that there are collies that are "ivermectin sensitive" and those that are considered to be "ivermectin non-sensitive" based on the results of these studies. Unfortunately, to date, no research has provided us with the ability to differentiate between the ivermectin-sensitive and non-sensitive collies.
Despite the studies being done, Ivermectin is not considered safe for collies by most breeders. Although Merck has recently removed its warning, there are now several cases of toxicity reactions reported from collies given Ivermectin. There have also been numerous reports of subclinical toxic reactions from dogs given Heartgard preventative. It is thought that there may be a wider range of sensitivity than indicated by the trials. The drug can be very toxic to Collie, Border Collie, Australian Shepherd, and Collie cross dogs. Therefore great consideration should be used in treating these breeds with an Ivermectin based preventative. To be completely safe, Collies and collie breeds should be given either carbamazine heartworm preventative (daily dose), or the monthly Interceptor heartworm preventative.
MILBEMYCIN OXIME (INTERCEPTOR & SENTINEL made by Novartis) is the chief competition of Heartgard30. This product is also given monthly, also clears microfilariae, acts by killing all L3s and L4s accumulated in the month prior to administration, and will suppress female worms ability to reproduce. There are a few important differences to note, though. If milbemycin is inadvertantly given to a dog with active heartworm disease, the dog may experience a serious shock syndrome if an especially high number of microfilariae are circulating.
When milbemycin is given to a dog after a prolonged period without heartworm preventive, the dog can be expected to have fewer heartworms than if heartworm preventive were not restarted. This was not as good a result as with the ivermectin product as the ivermectin product is better able to kill young adult heartworms. Milbemycin, however, is able to control roundworms, hookworms, and whipworms without the addition of a second parasiticide. It is also available combined with Lufenuron for the control of fleas. There are no breed- related sensitivities for milbemycin. Milbemycin oxime is also used effectively in the treatment of demodectic mange.
MOXIDECTIN (PROHEART made by Fort Dodge) is a derivative of ivermectin and the same rules that apply for Heartgard30 should apply to this new product. As is Heartgard30, ProHeart is a monthly tablet available in a 6-tablet package.
HOW OFTEN SHOULD A DOG BE TESTED?
If your dog is to begin taking a daily heartworm preventive ( Filaribits), life-threatening reactions can occur if this dog has circulating microfilariae at the time medication is started. Dogs using this product should definitely be tested annually. With differences in weather patterns every year (i.e. early Spring one year, late freeze another year etc.), it becomes difficult to figure out in what month heartworm preventive medication should be initiated. If there is any question about when the last possible transmission date was in the previous season, it is probably a good idea to simply test the dog annually. If there is any question about the dog spitting out any preventive tablets last season, then the dog should be tested before beginning prevention the next season. If the dog consistently takes monthly heartworm preventive medication all year round, then testing can probably be performed every 2-3 years (though an annual physical exam is needed to legally obtain a prescription for medication). If a dog lives in an area considered not to have heartworm and travels to an area that IS considered to have heartworm, both microfilaria and antigen testing should performed at least seven months after the last day the dog was present inthe heartworm endemic area. |